Six McKinley High musicals Playlist would have preferred to see over Grease, ft. Sam and Blaine.
- Guys and Dolls : Blaine as Sky Masterson / Sam as Nathan Detroit
- Book of Mormon : Blaine as Elder Price / Sam as Elder Cunningham
- The Producers : Blaine as Max Bialystock / Sam as Leo Bloom
- How to Succeed :
Darren Criss Blaine as J. Pierponte Finch / Sam as Bud Frump
- Wicked : Blaine as Elphaba / Sam as Glinda
- Damn Yankees : Blaine as Mr. Applegate / Sam as Joe Hardy